The backlash against Lupita Nyong’o began after rumours claimed that she would play Helen of Troy in Christopher Nolan’s planned version of The Odyssey.
Online critics questioned the casting, argued about “historical accuracy”, and debated beauty standards. Many others defended Nyong’o and called the criticism racist and colourist.
The controversy quickly grew into another major online debate about race, beauty, and representation in Hollywood. Much of the discussion focused on whether audiences would accept a Black actress in a role that many people traditionally associate with white European beauty. 
The outrage intensified after Elon Musk joined the conversation on X. He reposted and reacted to several comments that criticised the casting and questioned whether Nyong’o could represent Helen, the mythological figure famous for her beauty.
Conservative commentator Matt Walsh wrote on X that “not one person on the planet” considers Nyong’o “the most beautiful woman in the world”. Musk replied with one word: “True.”
READ ALSO: These White Hollywood That Are Actually South Africans
The comments triggered immediate backlash online. Critics accused Musk and others of promoting narrow Eurocentric beauty standards. Actor Alec Baldwin defended Nyong’o publicly, praised her beauty, and criticised the attacks against her.
Supporters of Nyong’o’s casting argued that Helen of Troy is a mythological character, not a real historical figure with one fixed appearance. They also noted that writers, artists, and filmmakers have reimagined The Odyssey in different ways for centuries.
Many critics of the backlash also argued that online debates about “accuracy” often target Black actors more harshly when they take roles traditionally played by white performers. As the debate continued, discussions moved beyond Greek mythology and focused more on race, identity, representation, and who audiences believe deserves iconic roles in modern cinema.
About The Author
Keep Up to Date with the Most Important News
